21 May 2025 Indian Express Editorial
What to Read in Indian Express Editorial( Topic and Syllabus wise)
Editorial 1 : What makes this face-off with Pak structurally different is China’s embedded role
Context
The recent bout of hostilities between India and Pakistan has once again exposed the fragility of deterrence in South Asia. This time, however, the conflict cannot be framed solely as a bilateral flashpoint.
Triggers are familiar
- While the triggers remain familiar cross-border provocation and military response the broader context has shifted significantly.
- The United States, returning to its well-worn role of crisis manager, has momentarily revived the India-Pakistan hyphenationthat New Delhi has long worked to dismantle.
- t demonstrates a credible shift from passive restraint to active deterrence.
- Domestically, it bolsters political legitimacy.Internationally, it signals that India will not tolerate a return to the era of consequence-free provocation.
- However, such tactical assertiveness must be weighed against strategic cost.
- Each military exchange, especially when it invites global mediation, draws India back into a regional frame it seeks to transcend.
- The goal must be to win engagements without re-entering a cycle that diminishes India’s identity as a global not merely South Asian actor.
- The reappearance of hyphenation in global discourse, particularly through American statements seeking to “own the ceasefire”, is a diplomatic regression.
- For over two decades, India has sought to decouple its international positioning from Pakistan, leveraging its economic scale, democratic governance, and global partnerships.
- India must engage diplomatically but reject frameworks that reduce its global profile to regional conflict management.
The US mediation
- The US’s posture has been cautious but familiar.
- During the first Trump administration, mediation was often offered impulsively, with Kashmir at times invoked as a bargaining chip in the broader Afghan calculus.
- The current US administration has reverted to a traditional playbookurging restraint, activating diplomatic channels, and engaging both sides with public neutrality.
- While this reflects institutional continuity, it also underscores the limits of trust in India-US relations when it comes to crisis scenarios.
- Despite deeper strategic ties spanning defence, technology, and Indo-Pacific cooperation the US’s reflex remains de-escalation over alignment.
Cautionary reminder for India
- For India, this is a reminder that strategic partnerships do not always translate into narrative control.
- Pakistan has seized the moment to showcase US involvement as a form of recognition.
- India must resist responding on those terms. Strategic maturity lies in letting others claim headlines while securing outcomes.
- India must continue deepening bilateral mechanisms with key partners like the US, where cooperation ranges beyond crisis flashpoints. That breadth is the best antidote to Pakistan’s narrow frame.
The re-evaluation
- The signalling around the Indus Waters Treaty raising the prospect of re-evaluating its operational commitments is a serious escalation cue.
- The treaty carries immense symbolic weight. India’s statements are likely aimed at increasing pressure without intending immediate disruption.
- Water is both a national and an ecological security issue, and changes to the Indus framework would invite international scrutiny, including from China.
- India must wield this instrument with caution visible enough to signal resolve, but restrained enough to avoid irreversible fallout.
Beijing’s role
- What makes this confrontation structurally different is China’s embedded role.
- Beijing is not merely a diplomatic shield for Pakistan but a material enabler.
- Pakistan’s current air capabilities are heavily influenced by Chinese platformsfrom the co-produced JF-17 to the advanced J-10C fighters, and from Wing Loong drones to HQ-9B air defence systems.
- Chinese systems allow Pakistan to reduce dependency on Western suppliers while gaining combat parity with Indian platforms like the Rafale.
- India must prepare for conflicts where adversaries are networked, platforms are interoperable, and escalation is layered with ambiguity.
The realistic front
- With this evolving configuration, the risk of episodic conflict becoming the norm is real.
- Limited engagements followed by quick ceasefires may prevent war, but they also entrench a cycle of confrontation.
- This rhythm serves neither India’s strategic ambitions nor regional stability.
- India must aim not just to deter conflict, but to shift the conflict paradigm. That requires both doctrinal innovation and narrative superiority.
- The global response, too, remains trapped in contradiction. While much of the world acknowledges India’s strategic maturity and global responsibilities, it defaults to treating South Asian crises as bilateral flare-ups needing urgent mediation.
- This undermines the idea of India as a stabilising Indo-Pacific power.
Way forward
- India’s diplomatic task is twofold:To internationalise its strategic vision while localising its disputes. That means engaging global institutions not merely as stakeholders in peace, but as validators of India’s wider role.
- In conflict, as in diplomacy, maturity lies not in escalation, but in the control of the terms of engagement.
Editorial 2 : FTA with UK marks India’s maturing global presence, readiness to lead growth
Context
The India-UK Free Trade Agreement (FTA) marks not just a high point in India’s trade negotiations but a transformative opportunity for Indian industry.
Trade between India and UK
- Historically, Indian exporters particularly in sectors like textiles, apparel, marine products, leather, and toys have been at a tariff disadvantage in developed markets like the UK.
- That changes now. With zero-duty access for nearly 99 per cent of Indian tariff lines, Indian firms finally enjoy a level playing field against competitors from the EU, Bangladesh and CPTPP countries.
- Consider apparel, Indian exports to the UK have been penalised by tariffs of up to 12 per cent while Bangladesh and China thrived on preferential access.
- Post-FTA, this handicap is eliminated.But this opportunity demands a mindset shift from commodity exports to branded, differentiated offerings for premium, regulated markets.
- India’s approach to the FTA reflects a calibrated strategy. While offering duty-free access to 85 per cent of UK products over a phased 10-year period, India has protected sensitive sectors such as dairy, apples, edible oils, smartphones and medical devices.
- This balance of openness with strategic autonomy ensures Make in India and employment-intensive sectorsare not disrupted. This should serve as a blueprint for future trade deals.
The FTA’s provisions
- The FTA’s most ambitious provisions lie in the services sector, a domain where India has a global edge.
- With enhanced market access for Indian IT, telecom, education, and financial services firms, and provisions that facilitate professional mobility, this agreement clears a long-standing barrierof Ease of deploying talent in the UK.
- The landmark Double Contribution Convention, which waives UK social security contributions for Indian professionals on temporary assignments, is not just a cost-saving tool.
- It will make Indian service exports even more competitive. Equally important is the mutual commitment to recognition of professional qualifications.
- Indian architects, accountants, engineers, and educators can now have seamless UK careers.
The benefits
- The FTA provides a platform for deep bilateral cooperation in investment, innovation, and research.
- With the UK’s strength in design, R&D and advanced manufacturing, and India’s strength in scale, talent, and execution, this agreement paves the way for joint IP creation, technology transfer, and co-manufacturing.
- Businesses must begin to see the UK not just as an export destination but as a partner in value chain innovation, where both countries can co-develop for global markets.
- For the first time, an Indian FTA includes chapters on labour rights, environmental protection, consumer welfare, gender equity and anti-corruption.
- These reflect India’s evolving economic maturity and its recognition that future trade will be governed by values and transparency, not just volumes. Indian businesses must now invest in compliance, ESG readiness and workforce diversity.
Suggestions
- To leverage this opportunity, Indian businesses must build UK-specific market strategies rooted in consumer insight, brand localisation, and agile fulfilment models.
- Invest in certifications, regulatory compliance, and product innovation to meet UK standards and expectations.
- Reskill and redeploy talent, especially in legal, financial, supply chain, and customer-facing roles.
- Form joint ventures and R&D partnerships with UK firms to accelerate innovation and de-risk expansion. Create feedback loops from UK market performance.
Way forward
- India’s long-term economic vision — Viksit Bharat — demands that we expand our share of global trade, move up the value chain, and create large-scale employment.
- The India-UK FTA is a major leap toward that vision. This is an inflexion point for India to transform from a cost-driven export economy to a value-creating global powerhouse.
![]()
